Economy in Brief: 2022

The all-sector IFO climate gauge fell to -20.1 in September from -13.4 and August, a sharp decline that represents erosion in all major categories. The manufacturing sector registered a -14.2 reading on climate in September, down from -6.8 in August; construction is at -21.6, down from -14.8 in August; wholesaling is at -26.4, down from -21.6 in August; retailing is at -39.8, down from -31.9 in August; and services fell into negative territory at -8.9 after logging a +1.4 reading in August. The readings are lower across the board and all the readings show net negative figures in September.

The percentile standings for the climate readings show how weak the rankings are. The all-sector index is at the 5.3 percentile on data back to 2005, manufacturing has a 7.7 percentile ranking, construction is at a 15-percentile ranking and that's the strongest sector overall. Wholesaling has a 4.3-percentile ranking, retailing has a 0.5-percentile ranking and services have a 1.6-percentile ranking. There is extreme cloudiness, thunderstorms in progress, with no silver linings.

There is simply relentless bad news in the German survey. It's been weakening for quite a period of time after peaking in 2018 and falling for Covid then peaking at a lower post-Covid peak in 2021. This month, rather than slowing down its pace of decline or beginning to reach a low point and flattening out, conditions have eroded and continued to deteriorate by a strong amount on the month. While there has been some let up in the relentless commodity price inflation, and oil prices have fallen from their high, Germany is being threatened by the shutting of the pipeline. That could result in severe energy source shortages over the winter. I believe people are starting to factor in a belief in the worst rather than to hope for the best as the war in Ukraine has turned worse for Russia. That worsening is going to put even more pressure on Russian President Vladimir Putin as it increases the probability that he will try to create as much disaster, dislocation, and chaos outside of his borders as he can using economic warfare- and other means.

The current conditions index also shows declines month-to-month. All sectors weakened on a month-to-month basis in September based on current condition assessments. However, only retailing has a net negative reading at -14. The all-sector current reading falls to 15.4 in September from 22.3 in August. Manufacturing falls to 12.8 from 18.4. The construction sector weakens to 6.9 from 12.6. Wholesaling weakens to 5.8 from 11.0. Services weakens to 22.7 from 30.9. The rankings by sector show readings that are uniformly in the lower 25th percentile or weaker in their respective historic queues of data. The sole exception is the construction sector that hovers above its median reading at 62.8 percentile.

Expectations readings also fell across the board on the month. The all-sector expectations reading fell to -42.3 in September from -31.3 in August. That reading has a -49.2 all-time low; this month's reading is at -42.3. The all-sector expectation reading has a 0.5 percentile standing; it has been weaker only 0.5% of the time since 2005. In fact, all the components have 0.5 percentile standings except manufacturing that has a 2.9 percentile standing and retailing that is at its historic low point.

The Confederation of British Industry (CBI) industrial trends survey for September registers an improvement in total orders. It moved up to a September reading of -2 from -7 in August. The reading had been +8 in July. The three-month average is zero, and that's against a six-month average of +10, and a 12-month average of +16. On that perspective, we can see that the assessment for orders has been deteriorating despite the small improvement month-to-month from August to September.

However, historically, the readings for orders tend to be weak. As a result, the -2 September reading is still strong-to-firm when measured against data from 1991 forward; September has a 75th percentile standing on that timeline. Over this period, orders have been higher than -2 only about one-quarter of the time. Over a more recent timeline, from 2015 forward, the ranking is at its 47th percentile, slightly below its median. The median for ranked data occurs at the 50th percentile. In broad historic context, this is still a relatively firm number; however, when compared to data since 2015, this is only an ordinary reading.

Export orders mimic the headline. They register a -8 in September which is an improvement from -12 in August; but August was unchanged from July. The August reading for export orders is stronger than its -11 three-month average although weaker than its -4 net reading for the six-month average and its -3 value for its 12-month average. The rank standings for export orders also mimics the rank standings for total orders. The ranking from 1991 is at a 70th percentile mark and the standing from 2015 has a slightly stronger but not too different at a 51st percentile mark. Once again, the orders are strong relative to the broader sample and weaker relative to the more recent sample since 2015 and the ranking on that latter period still registers near the neutral 50% reading.

The rating for the stocks of finished goods is stronger in September, up to +6 from +2 in August. This compares to a -7 reading in July and weaker readings over three and six months, but the much weaker 12-month average is at -9. The stocks readings are always hard to evaluate since rising inventories could be a sign of confidence or could be a sign of sales not going very well, leading to unintended inventory accumulation.

Looking ahead, industrial output volume for the next 3 months has a pronounced drop, falling to -17 compared to -2 for August. July had a + 6 reading making the three-month average -4; that compares to a six-month average of +8 and a 12-month average of +18. The outlook has deteriorated quite sharply over this period with September being a watershed, with the bottom falling out of the outlook. In fact, the ranking for the September value for the output outlook is in the bottom 5.8 percentile of its historic queue of data back to 1991. That's an extremely weak reading; over the more up-to-date comparison from 2015, the ranking is still in the bottom 7.7 percentile, not much different. Industry in the U.K. appears to be battening down the hatches and preparing for a storm ahead, a common theme among western European economies.

One reason for this dismal outlook on production may be the outlook for prices. Average prices expected over the next three months stepped up slightly in September to a reading of +59 from +57 in August. Like the data above, these are still net diffusion readings but with much higher values. Those recent readings compare to a reading of +48 in July. Compared to the sequential averages, the September reading is only slightly lower than the +61 reading for the six-month average and the +65 reading for the 12-month average. Given how much inflation has progressed, the outlook for inflation in the U.K. does not appear to have improved very much. There appears to be a lot of inflation pessimism there and that pessimism is also reflected in weak expected output.

The data for industrial production (IP) lag the CBI survey data which are quite up to date since it's only late-September and we have a September estimate in the CBI already. Industrial data on IP are up to date through July and on that basis the monthly July change in industrial production in manufacturing was zero. The change over three months was +0.4% at an annual rate; there's a roughly 2% annual rate decline over six months and a 1.1% rate of increase over 12 months. The performance of manufacturing industrial production during this period has been weak with a tangible decline. The ranking for the overall growth rate for manufacturing industrial production leaves it in its lower 36th percentile over both ranking periods since 1991 and from 2015. That’s a lower one-third reading and the economy is still growing- some fear recession lies ahead.