The UK inflation report in October is definitely not a good report but it's not a terrible report either; some of the more positive aspects of it are hidden to some extent in the details of the report.
The HICP version of inflation shows the headline rise of 0.3% in October after rising 0.5% in September and in August, each. The CPIH has the same headlines. The core reading for the CPIH was up by 0.2% in October, after a gain a 0.4% in September and 0.2% in August. These are excessive increases; however, the 0.2% monthly increase comes close to a desired result since the annualized to about 2.4% versus a target of 2%. Its is the 0.4% increase in September that is clearly out of line.
Inflation acceleration is muted Looking up and down the details of the October report, there are 4 categories that have increases of only 0.1% and there are two categories, education, and restaurants & hotels, which have declines in prices month-to-month. This stretch of good inflation news brings our attention to the diffusion or breadth of inflation acceleration which, in October, was only at 33%. That is there were only 33% of the categories showing acceleration month-to-month. This follows the 50% reading for acceleration diffusion in September and a 41.7 percent reading in August. The sequential data over three-months six-months and 12-months show the acceleration diffusion at 41.7% over 3-months, 58.3% over 6-months and 41.7% over 12-months. The diffusion data sequentially compares 3-month inflation to six-month inflation, 6-month inflation to 12-month inflation, and 12-month inflation to 12-month inflation of 12-months ago.
Broadly inflation is too high by a wide margin However, inflation is broadly excessive looking at year-over-year inflation; 83% of the categories have readings above 2%. Taken as a ranking over data back to 2000, this proportion of excess has about an 87-percentile standing. That means having a higher proportion of categories with inflation above 2% occurred only about 13% of the time back to the year 2000. So, things may not be worsening in an acceleration sense, but by historic comparison, current conditions rank poorly against past results.
An excessive core pace So, inflation is broadly over the top and while it is excessive it's not broadly accelerating however it's still excessive. A chart at the top shows what this looks like in terms of core inflation. The core price has picked up over 2% but then it's come back down to some extent, however, it remains above the 2% mark that the Bank of England would like for inflation overall. We look at the core because can we exclude the volatile items to get a better idea of that part of the index for the inflation rate that is more enduring and less fickle and less subject to what we could call stop-go effects.
Excessive rankings for headline and core inflation The overall inflation rate for the HICP has the year over year ranking at a 73rd-percentile, the CPIH ranking is in its 84th-percentile, the core CPIH the ranking is in its 82nd-percentile. These are all clustered in the lower-to mid-80th-percentile range marking them as historically excessive. Only two categories have inflation rates that rank below their median back to the year 2000; those are food and nonalcoholic beverages with a 25.6-percentile standing and education, with a 19.8 percentile standing. All the rest have year-over-year inflation rates as of October that are above their historic median pace as established by data back to the year 2000.
Little comfort is excess even if it is mild- but especially if it is stubborn This statistic cannot comfort the BOE about the year-over-year pace of 3.6%; it's certainly higher than the central bank would like and with the six-month pace at 4.5% and the three-month pace spiraling to 5.3%, these are very uncomfortable readings. I am listing off the HICP numbers, although the CPIH numbers are quite similar. The core readings show inflation going from 3.1% over 12-months to 3.5% over 6-months to 3.5% over 3-months. Much less ominous-seeming. But, again, a core pace of 3.5% is pretty much going to be stuck at 3.5% for a while. The pace needs to be reduced by 1.5 percentage points which is going to take some doing; it certainly doesn't look as excessive as the headline rate is 5.3% (over three-months) but it's high.
More work to do at the BOE…but how much? Data suggest that the Bank of England will have more work to do it doesn't suggest that there is a pressing red-light emergency. At the last Bank of England policy meeting only one Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) member was looking to move rates up by 50-basis points, which was Catherine Mann who tends to be the most hawkish among the MPC members. The question, to some extent, is how decisively and quickly does the bank want to move inflation back down to the 2% mark that they have targeted?
Tolerant central banks permit ongoing excess inflation Central banks not just the BOE, but central banks generally, have been more permissive about missing their inflation targets and have been spending more attention on keeping unemployment from rising. A lot of government resources have been expended to preserve growth and low unemployment, putting most large G7 countries, behind the eight-ball when it comes to fiscal flexibility. And central bankers aware that the fiscal tools to deal with recessions - if one comes - are going to be more limited so they've been more careful in the way they conduct monetary policy. But an inflation rate left over the top for too long can solidify excessive inflation expectations and make getting inflation back down to the 2% target even harder. And keeping rates in the restrictive zone for longer in order to grind inflation expectations back down to 2% may not be the most intense pain, but that would be a long-lived pain for an economy to deal with.
Bankers live with their choices So, this essentially explains the dilemma in which central banks find themselves. This discussion is a good example of it. And, of course, the future remains uncertain and there could be another slug of trouble and another bout of inflation impulses ahead. The war in Ukraine could worsen or the situation in the Middle East could deteriorate. For ‘my money’ this situation would argue for central banks to get inflation down lower, sooner, so that if there were another shock, it could be dealt with from a lower inflation base rather than from a higher inflation base. But this is not the choice that central banks have been making. They have more or less uniformly, after finding inflation over the top, chosen a long slow glide path to get inflation back down to 2% crossing their figures that there won't be other shocks along the way. But, of course, there have been other shocks along the way and there may be more of them. This is essentially the state of the conduct of modern monetary policy, not simply or solely the conduct of policy at the Bank of England. I do not see it changing much although, important, the US has a Fed chairman who will prove a better anchoring of inflation and inflation expectations in the period ahead.













Global
