Economy in Brief: 2024

In the wake of European Central Bank rate cuts, the European Monetary Union reports a 0.3% reduction in industrial production in July. Industrial production in the euro area shows a decline of 2.2% in output over 12 months; the rate of decline improves slightly to -1.6% when annualized over six months but then has a severe setback over three months as it falls at a 4.8% annual rate. You simply cannot put positive spin on this month’s report or on the trend. The best we can is that year-on-year trends are not worsening; several are potentially encouraging if they persevere.

The patterns in manufacturing are the same but manufacturing output declines at an 8.2% annual rate over three months, a much larger decline than for output overall. Sectors show some upbeat trends for consumer goods, as output is up by 1.6% over 12 months and then continues to advance at a 4.3% annual rate over six months and over 12 months. The increase in overall consumer goods output is underpinned by a steady acceleration in nondurable goods output and held back by declines in durable goods output over 12 months, six months and three months. Intermediate goods output faces a decelerating profile, with output falling 3% over 12 months, falling at a 3.7% annual rate over six months, and falling at a 6% annual rate over three months. The capital goods progression is not as steadily deteriorating, but it's a chilling development since output falls by 5.1% over 12 months, then that decline is trimmed to -2.9% at an annual rate over 6six months, but it comes back to show a 12.6% decline at an annual rate over three months. That's not a clean steady deterioration but the 12.6% pace of decline over three months is certainly chilling.

In the quarter-to-date, which is at this point a nascent calculation, one-month into the new quarter. Overall output falls at a 3.9% annual rate, manufacturing output falls at a 5.3% annual rate, consumer goods output is rising strongly pushed ahead by nondurable goods output. But apart from that, there are ongoing sharp declines in consumer durables output, the output of intermediate goods, and then the output of capital goods.

The performance of industrial output in July supports the decision by the ECB to cut rates even though that decision occurs with inflation over the top of its target and still accelerating. However, the factory sector has been weak for quite some time and the services sector has been strong enough to provide overall expansion for the economy. The goods sector is simply the weakest part of the economy and so it's going to seem like it is in support of any policy step taken to offset weakness.

EMU member countries The country level data for 13 of the earliest European Monetary Union members shows output declines in July in six of these reporters. In June, there were output declines in five of them; in May, there were output declines in seven of them.

Sequential calculations show that output has been increasing less broadly from 12-months to 6-months to 3-months. Over 12 months about two-thirds of the reporting countries showed output increases/ Over six months that fell back to 50% of them, whereas over three months only a little better than one-third of the reporting monetary union members are indicating accelerating output. In addition to that, over the last three months eight countries show actual declines in output in progress.

These are not your father’s or grandfather’s central banks. Oh, the names are the same (well, except for the ECB which didn’t exist ‘a generation’ ago). The behavior would be unrecognizable to those who knew Fed policy under Paul Volcker/Alan Greenspan or Bundesbank policy under Karl Otto Poehl and his legacy mates.

What has happened? Is it inflation targeting or is it something more?

INFLATION TARGETING IS FAILING...Instead of working as Ben Bernanke said it would, getting markets to see what central banks want and then acting to make that happen reinforcing the target goal, Central banks have instead used targeting as crutch to promise the target and deliver something else. This dissonance will eventually weigh on central bank credibility and undermine the process that Bernanke said would help banks to achieve their target.

ECB HICP inflation is not that far from its target, but momentum is in the wrong direction and inflation has been over target since early 2021 (38 consecutive months). Core inflation in the EMU is far too high (data lag by one month) and core inflation is accelerating- again moving in the wrong direction.

Some weakness, yes, but is it all that serious? The ECB speaks of a concern about weaker growth, but few of the early reporting EMU members display GDP declines in Q2. Among the 14 EMU members, I have data for only Austria, Germany and Ireland log declines in GDP Q/Q as of 2024-Q2. Austria, Finland, and Ireland log declines in GDP on four-quarter changes – that’s a more serious issue. Among the five EMU member countries that report composite PMI data to S&P, only Germany has a diffusion reading below 50 (indicating contraction). The EMU reading is 51.1 and it improved in August. EMU composite data ranked over the last 4 ½ years has a 51-queue percentile standing putting just above its median for the period (median occurs at 50). France, Italy, and Spain all have queue-standings above their respective 50th percentiles. Ireland and Germany are exceptions; Germany’s queue-standing is weak at the 28.6 percentile. The EMU’s largest economy has been weaker in terms of year-on-year growth only about 25% of the time.