German IP Drops Sharply in March; Trend Is Unclear and Muddied by Component Trends As Well

German industrial production fell by 3.4% in March driven lower largely by a 4.4% decline in capital goods along with a 3.5% decline in the output of intermediate goods. Consumer goods output backtracked by 0.1% in March.

Sequential growth paths The sequential growth rates for output in Germany paint a mixed picture with 12-month growth at 1.6%, 6-month performance showing a decline of 0.4%, at an annual rate, and 3-month growth surging at a 9.5% annual rate, despite the sharp drop in March. The 3-month period is largely bolstered by substantial increases in January and February when output rose by 3.7% in January and 2.1% in February. As a result, the March drop is a partial backtracking from that strength.

Sector trends in German output However, the components of German industrial production do not paint a particularly strong picture with a good deal of weakness portrayed over 6 months and 12 months, largely offset by some strength over 3 months; the exception is capital goods that reverses those patterns. Capital goods output is strong over 12 months and 6 months then falls at a 4.8% annual rate over 3 months. Intermediate goods have the opposite pattern, with output falling over 6 months and 12 months then rising at a 21.2% annual rate over 3 months. Consumer goods output declines over 6 months and 12 months, then makes a marginal increase at a 1.6% annual rate over 3 months. As a result of these scattered trends, the true trend for production overall in Germany is simply too turbulent to nail down.

Construction gains momentum In the construction sector, output fell by 3.1% in March after sharp gains in February and January. Construction does show acceleration and progress with 12-month rate at -2.7%, 6-month growth at 4.3% annualized, and 3-month growth at a stunning 39.8% annual rate.

Real sales and order trends Real manufacturing orders, however, show sequential weakness with a sharp drop of 10.7 March and with 12-month growth at -11%, 6-month growth at -13.2% annualized, and 3-month growth at -22.5% annualized. Real manufacturers’ sales also are challenged. Real sales in manufacturing point lower with growth of 3.8% over 12 months, a 3.7% annual rate decline over 6 months, and a sharper 8% annual rate drop over 3 months. Real sales in manufacturing also fell in March by 2.9%.

Other industrial indicators Other industrial indicators for Germany also create a mixed picture.

ZEW: The index from ZEW remains negative and it weakened in March compared to February. Its sequential readings show deterioration. The 6-month average deteriorates from the 12-month average, but then an improvement occurs over three months compared to six months.

IFO: The IFO manufacturing index shows some tendency to increase with the 6-month and 12-month readings nearly identical and some improvement over 3 months; the monthly sequence from January to February to March, strengthens steadily. The IFO manufacturing expectations reading strengthens steadily from 12-months to 6-months to 3-months and strengthens from January to February to March. The IFO is the most upbeat reading for German manufacturing in the table.

EU Commission Indexes: The EU Commission industrial survey for Germany contrarily shows sequential weakening from 12-months to 6-months to 3-months and that signal is further reinforced by monthly sequential weakness from January to February to March.

The industrial indicators, as a group, paint a mixed picture of German manufacturing.

Other European IP reporters Other early reporters of industrial production data in Europe include France, Spain, Portugal, and Norway. France reports sequentially weakening output. Spain reports sequentially strengthening output. Portugal reports somewhat mixed trends but shows output declining on balance over all three horizons. Norway shows declines in output that worsen slightly over 6 months compared to 12 months; it still logs a gain over 3 months in the face of a small decline posted in March and no change at all in February.

Summing up On balance, the data show confusing trends. While there has been some strength in output early in the year, March does not show any clear continuation of that trend. German orders and sales paint a more dismal picture of the future while output itself has mixed trends. Surveys for Germany are mixed, and the performance of early reporting European countries also shows mixed trends.