Haver Analytics
Haver Analytics

Introducing

Robert Brusca

Robert A. Brusca is Chief Economist of Fact and Opinion Economics, a consulting firm he founded in Manhattan. He has been an economist on Wall Street for over 25 years. He has visited central banking and large institutional clients in over 30 countries in his career as an economist. Mr. Brusca was a Divisional Research Chief at the Federal Reserve Bank of NY (Chief of the International Financial markets Division), a Fed Watcher at Irving Trust and Chief Economist at Nikko Securities International. He is widely quoted and appears in various media.   Mr. Brusca holds an MA and Ph.D. in economics from Michigan State University and a BA in Economics from the University of Michigan. His research pursues his strong interests in non aligned policy economics as well as international economics. FAO Economics’ research targets investors to assist them in making better investment decisions in stocks, bonds and in a variety of international assets. The company does not manage money and has no conflicts in giving economic advice.

Publications by Robert Brusca

  • Denmark's manufacturing purchasing managers index (from the Danish Purchasing and Logistics Forum) has risen to 52.1 in October from 49.6 in September. This ends a three-month streak of the index being below 50 indicating a contraction in the sector. And it's coming off a period of extremely high readings - readings as high as of 70 back in June 2022 and readings of over 60 from March through May before that.

    In October, there was an increase in the headline PMI, an increase in new orders, and an increase in production which we tend to view as the most important readings for the index. However, they are not the totality of the index. Weaker on the month was the employment reading, delivery speeds slowed, purchased inventories weakened, purchase prices weakened, the quantity of purchases weakened, and inventories of finished goods also weakened. Out of 8 components only 2 strengthened.

    Looking at momentum, the month's increase in October has tended to put a more positive spin on trend. The three-month change in the Danish manufacturing PMI index is positive; in fact, the three-month change is higher for all the components as well, except for the prices of purchased goods. This is less because of the gain in October and more because the three-month comparison is off a base in July that showed exceptional and not-representational weakness. Over six months conditions are slightly more mixed. The headline is still stronger, orders and production are stronger; in fact, most of the components are stronger, except for a weakening of employment and for purchase of inputs and for the prices of purchased inputs. The 12-month change shows lower readings everywhere: the headline is lower, and all the components are lower.

    Over the last 12 months the headline has an average rating of 57.7 which is stronger than the October reading of 52.1. Most of the components have readings above 50 for their 12-month averages indicating expansion. The exceptions are inventories of purchased inputs and the inventories of finished goods. Both of those inventory figures are below a diffusion value of 50 indicating that on balanced there has been ongoing contraction for inventories. Both inventory measures are decreasing, firms are holding smaller volumes of finished goods and as a result they're also holding smaller volumes of purchased inputs. However, the quantity of purchases has been holding up with the 12-month reading average of 58.7 although that metric takes a beating this month as it falls to 26.2.

    While the manufacturing sector shows that there has been expansion and expansion in most of the categories over 12 months on average, in October we see some significant weakening compared to the average. The quantity of purchases, in fact, has the weakest reading with the diffusion value of 26.2 in October; the next weakest reading is delivery speeds indicating that firms can fill orders extremely quickly, hinting at some spare capacity. Inputs of inventory are at 49.9 in October, stronger than the inventories of finished goods which are at a reading of 41.5. While we found that there were increases across most components on the month, a closer look at this finds the new orders reading only at 51.0, barely showing expansion after weak readings showed contraction in the earlier three months.

    The Danish data are confusing since we see some important topical weakness in October and yet we see broad improvements over the last three months. The reasons it's broad improvements over the last three months is that four months ago in June there was an extremely strong diffusion reading for the headline at 70 and corresponding strong readings up and down the line for the components. Still, the base for the three-month comparison is distorted sapping these gains of their meaning

    Moreover, when we look at the current readings compared to values of 12 months ago, we find declines up and down the line with the exceptions ironically only for the two inventory measures. Over 12 months the manufacturing PMI itself is lower by some 19 diffusion points, new orders are lower by some 25 diffusion points, delivery speeds are lower by 50 diffusion points, and the quantity of inputs purchased is lower by nearly 48 diffusion points.

    Ranking the Danish PMIs in October The ranking of the October data on values back to the year 2000, a better than 20-year frame of comparison, gives us a headline PMI with a 28.8 percentile standing which places that well below its historic median. The median for the ranking statistics always occurs at a ranking of 50. Values above 50 are above their median and values below 50 are below their median. For Danish manufacturing, our values are below their median except for inventories of inputs which have a 73-percentile standing. After that, the next strongest reading is for the prices of purchases, which have a 43.4 percentile standing still, below their median. The weakest reading in October over this 20 plus year period is for the quantity of purchases with a 1.1 percentile standing. These data clearly began to look like Danish manufacturers are starting to batten down the hatches and prepare for demand slowdown. The quantity of purchases is extremely weak, and their delivery speeds are extremely fast with a 5.8% standing; low readings on delivery speeds mean that delivery speeds are fast- slow readings and delivery speeds indicate more heated economic activity. In this case, no lags have crept into the process. New orders have only a 21.2 percentile standing, and employment has only a 25.5 percentile standing.

  • In October, the manufacturing readings worsen in 16 of the 18 reporting countries/regions. However, of 18 countries and regions reporting in the table, only eight show manufacturing PMI values above 50 indicating that their respective manufacturing sectors are still expanding.

    The countries that show manufacturing expanding in October according to the S&P manufacturing PMIs are India, the United States, Brazil, Indonesia, Vietnam, Japan, Russia, and Mexico. Taiwan has the weakest manufacturing reading in the table in October at 41.5, Germany’s reading is 45.7, Turkey registers 46.4, and the European Monetary Union comes in at 46.6. Those best-worst comparisons show the economic performances mixed between the largest and the smallest economies as of October; however, nothing is particularly strong. The strongest reading in the table is India at 55.3 and after that Indonesia at 51.8. These are not impressive numbers.

    The sequential comparisons show that over three months there are only three countries that are improved over three months compared to their six-month averages; over six months there are only four countries that are improved compared to their 12-month averages; over 12 months there are seven countries that are improved compared to their 12-month averages from 12-months ago. The breadth of improvement is on the decline from 12 months to six-months to three-months that's clear. Over three months the countries that report improvement are Russia, India, and Indonesia. Over six months the countries that report improvement are Mexico, Russia, India, and Brazil. Over 12 months the countries that register improvement are Japan, China, Russia, India, Indonesia, Malaysia, and Vietnam. Given the sanctions imposed on Russia, and other anecdotal evidence, the Russian PMI reports for manufacturing are suspect….

    The percentile standing data on the far right of the table show that there are only three countries that have readings this month that are above their historic medians calculated over the last 4 ½ years; those three countries are Mexico, Russia, and Indonesia. Taiwan is showing the weakest reading of this period. France’s reading is a bottom 6% and it is joined by Canada, the U.K., the U.S., and the euro area as countries or economic units that have standings in the lower 10 percentile of their historic ranges. The median standing for the full queue rankings in October is a 20.8 percentile standing, an extremely weak figure for the median.

  • Growth in the European Monetary Union in the third quarter gained 0.7% at an annual rate quarter-to-quarter. This is a sharp deceleration from the 3.3% annualized growth rate in the second quarter as well as from the 2.4% annualized growth rate in the first quarter. Growth year-over-year has now decelerated to 2.1% in the third quarter compared to a 4.3% growth rate in the second quarter.

    Inflation rises Not only is growth slowing but the inflation rate has risen. Inflation in October has risen to a 10.7% annual rate, its highest increase year-over-year in this cycle. Despite the slowing in GDP, there is no break on the inflation side. Over six months inflation escalates further to an 11.1% annual rate and over three months inflation cooks at a 13% annualized rate. The inflation situation remains intense while growth is slowing.

    Among members growth mostly decelerates in the quarter Only a handful of countries' specific GDP numbers are available for the third quarter. In France, GDP is up at a 0.6% annual rate, slowing from a 2% pace in the second quarter. Germany's growth accelerated to 1.1% quarter-over-quarter pace, compared to 0.4% in the second quarter. Italian growth slows to 2% annual rate in the third quarter from 4.4% in the second quarter. Growth in Portugal is up to 1.6% annual rate compared to 0.4% in the second quarter, and finally Spain grows at a 1% annual rate in the second quarter, a sharp shift from the 6% annual rate in the second quarter.

    Large EMU economies do better The four largest economies in the European Monetary Union have growth at 1.1% in the third quarter compared to 2.4% in the second quarter. For the rest of the euro area, growth in Q3 declines by 0.3% at an annual rate in Q3 compared to gaining 5.9% at an annual rate in the second quarter.

    Large vs. Small EMU economies Year-over-year growth rates are slower across the European Monetary Union; for the four largest economies the growth rate averages 1.7% in the third quarter compared to 3.7% in the second quarter. For the rest of the EMU, a third quarter rate of 3.2% year-over-year compares to 5.8% in the second quarter. Both the largest and the smallest economies show a downshifting and growth of two percentage points or more based on the year-over-year growth rates. Year-on-year growth rates favor the smaller economics that are nonetheless weaker in the current quarter.

    Growth slows broadly across countries Growth slows in the third quarter for each of the five economies that separately report data as well as for the European Monetary Union measure based on 19 countries. However, each country has its own tendency to grow; the table evaluates the growth rate for each of these units compared to its historic tendency. The European Monetary Union's growth ranking for the year-over-year rate for the third quarter is in its 64th percentile. For the four largest economies, the growth rate is in the 60th percentile. Portugal's growth has a 93.5% standing while Italy's growth has an 85.9 percentile standing. Growth in Spain has a 75-percentile standing. However, Germany has only a 40.2 percentile standing, and France has only a 29.3 percentile standing.

    U.S. trends are different During the same time, U.S. growth has a 35.2 percentile standing on a year-over-year growth rate of 1.8% that is essentially unchanged from its second quarter pace and for a third quarter growth rate of 2.6% that accelerates from a -0.6% rate in the second quarter. Comparing the U.S. to Europe, it's clear that there are very different things going on in Europe compared to the U.S. although both economic units are showing elevated and difficult inflation outcomes.

  • Among the 11 early reporters of the PPI (or in the case of Austria, the wholesale price index), the median increase in September was a rise of 0.2%. This is a downshift from the 3.6% increase in August but an improvement from the 0.2% decline in July. Europe is clearly in a period where prices are somewhat volatile in the wake of some energy price and commodity price instability.

    However, the overall median for 12-months, 6-month, and 3-month price changes for the PPI excluding construction among EMU members shows a deceleration in the pace from 35.6% over 12 months to 25.6% over six months to 20.8% over three months. This is some significant deceleration; however, the pace of inflation is still tremendously high.

    The results in the table are for September 2022. They show an increase of 35.6%. One year ago, the year-on-year increase was 17.4%. The year before that, the 12-month period ended September 2020 had the year-over-year PPI median fall by 3.2 percentage points.

    The PPI is most volatile of the 'major' inflation statistics because it's weighted toward commodities and oil, goods that have been bearing the brunt of the inflation process recently. In the table, Ireland shows some of the most outrageous increases for the PPI over three months, six months, and 12 months. Setting its wild numbers aside, Germany has the highest percent gain over three months at 84.6%. Over six months, again, Germany posts the largest gain at 53.5%. But over 12 months the largest annual gain is from Italy at 53.2%, followed by Belgium at 49.5%, and then Germany at 46.9%. On the same profile, the weakest increase over three months is from Austria at -8.9%; over six months there's a decline of 6.1% in Greece; over 12 months there's much more clustering but the weakest gain is from Austria at 20.6% followed by Portugal at 21.6% and Finland at 24.6%.

    The PPI for 12-months ago - its 12-month increase for the period ended in September 2021 - shows a median gain of 17.4%. However, clustered around that median gain, the lowest increase in the table is France at 11.9%, stepping up to Germany at 13.4% and Portugal at 15.5%. At the top end, the biggest gainers are Ireland's 82%, a 25.6% increase in Belgium and a 23.9% increase in Spain.

    Inflation shows some significant variability but clearly the pace has been high and one of the key reasons has been oil prices.

    We have two early observations on a PPI excluding energy; one comes from Germany and the other is the number from the U.K. (which is no longer an EU member). The U.K. number is a core number excluding food, tobacco, beverages, and petrol. Both the German and the U.K. figures increase by 0.5% in September and by 0.4% in August. They diverge in July with a 0.4% increase in Germany and a 1.3% increase in the U.K. Sequential data show a tendency for the ex-energy or core inflation rates to abate but the progression is not absolute. In Germany and the ex-energy pace for inflation goes from 13.8% over 12 months up to a pace of 15% over six months then down sharply with a 3.8% pace over three months. In the U.K., the core rate goes from a 16.4% increase over 12 months up to 18.9% pace over six months and then down to a pace of 12.2% over three months. In both cases, the three-month pace is sharply lower than either the six-month or the 12-month pace.

    The ex-energy or core inflation reported by Germany and the U.K. show an annual rate pace that hovers around the 15% area more or less and that is considerably better than the median, 35.6% annual rate, for all the countries in September.

  • Italian consumer confidence sank in October to 90.1 from 94.8 in September. The index has been engaged in a sinking trend since it peaked early in the recovery from the COVID crisis. The peak for the index was experienced in October 2021, the first month of data where observations became available for this survey after COVID struck and resulted in a one-month suspension of the survey in September 2021.

    Consumer confidence is lowered by 8.3% over three months and by 23.9% over 12 months. The mean for confidence is at level 102 whereas the October value at 90.1 is substantially below this marker. The distribution of observations for confidence is such that the 90.1 level for the October index is at its 5.9 percentile ranking, which means confidence has been weaker than this less than 6% of the time on data back to 1997.

    The evaluation of the overall situation (over the last 12 months) deteriorated sharply in October, falling to -138 from a -122 value in September. There's a sharp deterioration from August. The overall situation has fallen by 15 points over three months and 94 points over 12 months. The standing for the overall situation, a reading that applies to the last 12 months, is also in its lower 6 percentile.

    The situation expected over the next 12 months improved in October. It rises to a reading of -13 from -19 in September and compares to a much weaker -22 level in July. The index is 44 points lower than it was 12-months ago but nine points higher than it was three months ago. The reading sits in the 29th percentile of its historic queue of data, telling us that it's been weaker less than 30% since May 1997.

    Looking ahead to unemployment over the next 12 months, there's a slight deterioration to a reading of 20 and by that, I mean that the expectation for unemployment has risen; it's risen to +20 in October from +19 in September; it was at a level of 10 in July. Unemployment expectations are up by 10 points over three months and up by 26 points over 12 months. Unemployment expectations have been higher than this only 13% of the time since 1997. Concerns over unemployment clearly have risen and are now a palpable for the Italian worker.

    The household budget for 12-months ahead show deterioration to +11 in October from +14 in September and it stands lower than it's been over the last four months; the budget assessment is down by 5 points over three months and down by 15 points over 12 months. Its standing is at its 52.5 percentile, which leaves it slightly above its historic median (it is also above its mean). This is one of the few readings the table that is not extreme.

    The household financial situation over the last 12 months has a -55 reading in October, down sharply from -41 in September, and clearly the weakest reading in the last four months and below its historic mean which sits at a -36 level. The household financial situation over the previous 12 months has been evaluated as weaker than this only 11% of the time. However, it's the financial situation looking over the next 12 months that is most worrisome. It has fallen to a level of -41 in October compared to -36 in September and has the weakest reading over the last four months; it's fallen by 5 points over three months and fallen by 42 points over 12 months. The October reading now sits at the lowest level that it has experienced since May 1997. Concerns by Italians over their household financial situation have never been more extreme.

    The environment for household savings improved for the current period. However, the reading for the future deteriorated. The assessment of the current period is 7 points higher over 12 months while the future expectation is weaker by 5 points over 12 months. The current assessment has a 92.8 percentile standing, which is extremely high, although future assessment has a 66.9 percentile standing, that is a top two-thirds standing which is moderately firm.

    The assessment of the time being right to make a major purchase currently fell to -52 in October from -42 on September. This response is 13 points lower over three months and 41 points lower over 12 months. It has a 6.6% standing on data since May 1997. Consumers are obviously concerned about making major purchases and about unemployment, and these are major reasons while consumer confidence overall is so weak.

    The business confidence index also deteriorated in October, falling to 100.4 from September’s 101.2. The current reading for October is the lowest over the last four months and it's fallen by 5.3% over three months and by 12.5% over 12 months. The business index has a 32-percentile standing, placing it the lower one-third of its historic queue of values.

  • French consumer confidence rebounded in October to 81.9 from a reading of 79.5 in September. The 81.9 level is close to the August level of 82.2 and this reading has been fluctuating in a range of 82 to 79 for the past five months. Today's reading is not a surprise; it's not news; the month-to-month fluctuation is not significant. It's simply an indication that confidence remains in this very low habitat where it's been in the aftermath of the Fed beginning to raise rates aggressively in March and the start of the Russia-Ukraine war in February.

    Living standards over the last 12 months in France posted a -79 reading, the same as in September, among the weaker readings over the last five months. The outlook for living standards over the next 12 months has a -64 reading that stacks up as one of the stronger readings over the last five months but not by a lot.

    Expected unemployment over the next 12 months has a +23 reading the same as in September. These two numbers are significant steps up from what they had been from June to August. Price developments show prices over the last 12 months with the reading of 61 which is in the middle of where they've been for the last five months. The reading over the next 12 months is flat that leaves it hovering and just slightly weaker territory than it's been for most of the last five months.

    The assessment of whether it's a favorable time for savings declined month-to-month to a reading of 26 in October from 31 in September, but these generally reflect stronger readings than for the previous three months. The ability to save over the next 12 months has a -5 reading, the same as in September and these represent deteriorated readings over the last five months.

    Responses to the survey question 'is it a favorable time to make a major purchase' log a -37 reading in October which is roughly where it's been over the last five months - not much change.

    Households assessed their financial situation over the last 12 months as a -29 reading, a slight improvement from where it had been in the previous four months. The assessment for the next 12 months has a -23 reading which is only slightly improved from its habitat over the last five months.

    Where these readings ranking In terms of the rankings for these various responses, the household confidence index has a 3.1 percentile ranking (standing) which is extremely weak although it's only in the same territory that it's been over the last five months or so. This is a lower 3% of habitat reading among all readings since 2001 and that's a period of nearly 22 years. Living standards both past and expected for the next/pervious 12 months also have extremely weak readings in their lower 3 percentile. Unemployment expectations stand higher in their 34th percentile; workers are beginning to get a little concerned over the outlook for unemployment. Price developments show that prices over the past 12 months as well as over the next 12 months have a 95 to 97 percentile standing compared to historic expectations. Inflation has been and is expected to remain high. The favorability of the environment to save is good with an 81.2 percentile standing. However, the ability to save over the next 12 months is more moderate with the roughly 60th percentile standing. The favorability of making a major purchase is a lower three percentile standing in the same weak relative habitat as the household confidence and living standard standings. The financial situation over the last 12 months is assessed at a 21-percentile standing. But looking to the next 12 months conditions are expected to worsen with only a 7-percentile standing. Clearly these are challenging times for French households and are recognized as such.

    Pre-COVID comparisons are disappointing The transition of these current readings compared to the pre-COVID. Show a great deal of weakness the household confidence index is weaker by 23 points, living standards are weaker by over 40 points, the ability to save is weaker by four points, the spending environment is weaker by 27 points, the financial situation both current and next are between 15 to 20 points weaker. The things that are stronger are not improvements they include is the expectation for unemployment that is 25 points higher and the readings on price developments over the past 12 months that are 95 points higher and for the next 12 months that are 23 points higher. However, the favorability of the environment for saving also shows improvement compared to the pre-COVID; that reading is 20 points higher.

  • United Kingdom
    | Oct 25 2022

    U.K. CBI Orders Erode in October

    U.K. survey gives a mixed view of short-term industrial trends The U.K. survey from the Confederation of British Industry (CBI) on industrial data shows total orders at a -4 reading in October compared to a -2 reading in September and -7 in August. Despite this waffling short-term progression, strength in orders has been slipping more broadly with a 12-month average at +14, a six-month average at +7 and a three-month average at -4. The October orders reading itself has a queue standing on data from 2015 at its 41st percentile, below its median (the median resides at a level of 50th percentile). However, on longer-dated data back to 1991, the queue standing for the orders variable is substantially stronger at its 70.6 percentile, well above its median. The U.K. economy has been relatively stronger since 2015 accounting for the lower standing of the October reading over this more recent period. Evaluated over the longer time series of data, the current reading is less troubling and relatively firm compared to the short-dated observations. These differing baselines make it more difficult to evaluate the U.K. readings with confidence.

    The U.K. situation However, none of these observations mask the fact that the U.K. economy is weakening and that it faces turmoil in its financial markets, weakness for the pound sterling, and political difficulties, having just placed its third Prime Minister in office this year. Inflation in the U.K. remains high although it shows signs of having peaked and, perhaps, it is ready to move lower. But current inflation in the U.K. is too high and the task ahead for the Bank of England is made more difficult by the fact that the economy has weakened.

    The rest of the current survey The CBI survey shows weak export orders at a -14 reading in October from -8 in September and -12 in August. This series has an average of -4 over 12 months as well as over six months that deteriorates to an average of -11 over three months. The order series for exports has a queue standing in its 37th percentile on data back to 2015 but improves to a 55.4 percentile standing on data back to 1991. One reading has a weak standing; the other is moderate

    Stocks of finished goods have an October reading a +7 compared to +6 in September and +2 in August. The 12-month average is -7, rising to -1 over 6 months and to +5 over three months. Inventory levels are showing some signs of having been rebuilt. With orders fading, this may not be a desired trend.

    The outlook Looking ahead, the U.K. output volume reading for the next three months has improved to +7 in October from -17 in September and -2 in August. However, looking back at the time series, the average over 12 months is 16, the average over six months is +6 and the average over three months is -4. The sequential averages show that there's a deterioration in the outlook for output volume three-months ahead even though the October monthly figure itself shows a strong turnaround from a very weak reading in September. We know enough about the U.K. economy, and its difficulties to be somewhat skeptical about the notion that there has been a sharp turnaround in the output volume outlook.

    One of the reasons that the output outlook for the U.K. economy remains difficult and strained is because of inflation. In October the outlook for prices three-months ahead fell to 46 from 59; the August reading had been 57. The 12-month average for the outlook for prices three-months ahead is 64 following a reading of 57 over six months and 54 over three months. There is a monthly progression showing pressure is coming off prices and a sequential average progression that reinforces that trend. That's good news; however, the price level numbers are still extremely strong. The price reading for October- despite its decline- still has an 83.3 percentile standing on data since 2015 and a 96.6 percentile standing on data from 1991. That's the inflation part of the outlook. Output volume over the next three months has only a 33.3 percentile standing compared to data since 2015 and only a 40.8% standing compared to data since 1991. Either way the look-ahead for output volume is below its median despite the fact that that series has improved in October. Inflation improvement is too small to be construed as good news yet.

    Industrial output readings lag but tell a clear story At the bottom of the table, we include the summary data for U.K. manufacturing output. The most up-to-date reading for that is in August and it shows a 1.6% drop month-to-month. The three-month change in output shows a 13.2% drop at an annual rate, the six-month change shows an 8.1% drop at an annual rate, the 12-month result shows a 6.7% drop. These progressive growth rates show how industrial output has been declining more rapidly over recent periods. And the ranking of the IP data over either period is unambiguously weak in the lower 2.7% of its queue on either timeline. However, the output data themselves from the industrial production indicator are only up to date through August. The CBI survey is up to date through October. But it is unlikely that those trends have turned around in any significant way because of the clear forces have been battering the economy and because of the impact on financial markets.

  • PMI data for October are weak on a broad front, falling for all composites in the table except for Japan and falling in all these sectors except for manufacturing in the U.K. and for services in Japan. In September, the U.S. is the exception with stronger readings for the composite, manufacturing, and services. Japan has a stronger composite and services reading in September as does France, but the United Kingdom, Germany, and the European Monetary Union all show weaker readings for all three components. In August, there are weaker readings for all the composites and most of the components with the exceptions only for manufacturing in France and manufacturing in the U.K. that both were stronger in August compared to July. The picture that emerges from this is widespread weakening.

    Three-month, six-month, and twelve-month data in the table I bet it's turn hard data they exclude the October reading which is a flash reading. Based on these averages, all the three-month readings are weaker than all the six-month readings. The six-month readings are weaker than all the 12-month readings except in Japan where both services and the composite are stronger. Over 12 months, there's more variability with 10 of the 18 readings stronger on the month.

    High-low standings The percentile standing which positioned the month’s reading relative to the high-low readings since January 2018 show relatively moderate and positive standings. The U.S. is the exception with a 48.6 percentile standing. Japan logs a 94th percentile standing; France logs an 80th percentile standing; the European Monetary Union logs a 71.4 percentile standing. However, these are the current index paced in a range relative to the highest and the lowest readings during this period. It's a much more powerful reading to look at the ranking of the current month among all the readings since January 2018.

    Queue standings The queue standings rank the current month among all the readings since January 2018 and here the rankings changed remarkably. Japan has the highest composite standing at its 72nd percentile. After the Japan reading, it drops all the way down to a 27.6 percentile standing in France and from that we're down to a 6.9% standing in the European Monetary Union, in the U.K., and in the U.S. There's clearly a proliferation of weakness. 11 of 18 queue percentile standings reside below the 15th percentile mark.

    The net drops in PMIs In October, the unweighted change among this group of countries and the EMU is for the composite to fall by 1.2 points, for manufacturing to fall by 0.9 points, and for the services reading to fall by 1.1 points. Over three months, the average drop is 1.9 points for the composite, 3.1 points for manufacturing and 1.9 points for services. Over 12 months, the average drop is 6.5 points for the composite, 8.9 points for manufacturing and 6.6 points for the composite.

    Comparisons to pre-COVID levels Compared to just before COVID struck, in January 2020, there are only four readings in the table that are above that January 2020 level. They are all the readings for Japan and the manufacturing reading for Germany – the German reading is higher by only 0.4 points. On average, since January 2020, the composites are weaker by 3.6 points, manufacturing is weaker by 1.4 points, and services are weaker about 4.0 points. The boom-bust cycle related to COVID has now left us at a net weaker level. Not only are the PMI readings weaker but they're decaying; they have more negative momentum.

  • The GfK measure of consumer confidence in the UK rebounded slightly in October to a -47 reading from a -49 level in September- which is its all-time low. The two-point bounce is extremely small given the weak level of the September reading. The outlook for the period ahead, over the next 12 months, sees slight improvements in the household financial situation and for the general economic situation, although both continue to have extremely weak readings when it set against the background of their historic range of values. Both those readings are weaker historically less than one-half of one percent of the time. Both readings reach all-time lows in September and rebound weakly in October. The outlook for unemployment continued to be moderate and fell in October.

    Retail sales are weak - Keep your eye on volume data The background in terms of the consumer confidence is extremely weak. It's not surprising that sales in September fell by 1.5% in nominal terms and by 1.4% in real terms. Over 12-months nominal sales are up by 3.8%, while real sales - sales volumes- are down by 6.9%. Inflation has become an extremely decisive factor in understanding anything in the UK economy. For example, the ranking of the year-over-year sales rate has a 60.2 percentile ranking in its historic queue of data. That’s a moderate reading, above its historic median. On the other hand, the ranking of the year-on-year percent change in real retail sales (volume) has a 0.8 percentile standing- a standing in the bottom 1% of its historic queue of data. Clearly, to understand what's going the inflation adjusted data are the way to go - and these data are weak.

    Sales volumes are weak, and weakness is accelerating Retail sales data show a decline of 6.9% over 12 months, they show decline of 8.2% at an annual rate over 6-months, and a decline of 11.4% at an annual rate over three months. UK retail sales are slipping, and they're rate of decline is accelerating. The economy appears to be careening toward recession with consumer spending this weak it would be hard to imagine the economy continuing to expand. In the quarter to-date retail sales volumes are down at a 7.3% annual rate; the volume number completes the economic picture for the third quarter. ONS has reported a DGP decline from July and August and has noted that growth of 1% in the economy for September would be necessary to prevent a quarterly decline. The recession cake appears to be in the oven and nearly baked.

    UK CBI survey confirms weakness Surveys of UK retail sales show marked deterioration in September compared to August, a Confederation of British Industry CBI) report shows. Retail sales for the time of year record a survey level of -10 compared to +12 in August. The CBI volume of orders measured year-over-year also shows a net negative -17 reading in September compared to +14 in August.

    The queue standings for these CBI readings are still not as weak as the retail sales volumes themselves. The retail sales for time of year have about 45-percentile standing while the volume of orders year-over-year has a weak 18.6-percentile standing. The CBI survey does show encroaching weakness, however, the weakness in real retail sales appears to be much more severe than what's being picked up by the survey at least as of September. And the survey in September took a sizable turn for the worse compared to August, so it could be that retailers are just beginning to appreciate the depth of their problem situation.

    Summing up Economic conditions in the UK clearly are weakening. Inflation rate is high; over 3-months (using the HICP as a benchmark) inflation is up by 6% and while that's down from the year-over-year pace of 10.1% it's still a high inflation rate and, in September, the measure advanced by 0.4% month-to-month not an indication that pressures are cooling very much. However, the Bank of England has a difficult job because the inflation rate is high and yet the economy is cooling – on the brink of recession. This will call for a very careful modulation of policy to control rising inflation and not to exacerbate the economic slide that appears to be underway. The UK also has political leadership problems: the recent resignation of the Prime Minister just set a record for the shortest term in the history of British politics. Now the government needs to reconvene and pick a new leader at a time that economic conditions are difficult and their choices, once again, are going to be contentious. The UK finds itself between a rock and a hard place at a time that global inflation is high, the global economy is sliding, there's a war in Ukraine, and energy prices continue to hover at high levels. It's not an enviable situation but it is what they face – a lot of tough choices.

  • Germany's PPI for September excluding construction rose 2.4% after a 7.9% monthly gain and in August and a 5.3% monthly gain in July. The three-month growth rate for the headline PPI is an astounding 83% annualized, as well as a 49% annual rate over 6-months and a 45% annual rate over 12-months. However, 12-months ago the year-over-year rate was rising at a 66% annual rate. Germany has been fighting off this headline inflation problem from the PPI for quite some time.

    The ex-energy inflation rate is much better behaved, but not without its problems. The PPI ex-energy rose by 0.5% in September after a 0.4% gain in August and in July. Over 3-months it's rising in a 5.1% annual rate, compared to an 11% annual rate over 6-months and a 13.8% annual rate over 12-months. One year-ago the PPI excluding energy was rising at an 8.6% annual rate.

  • United Kingdom
    | Oct 19 2022

    UK CPI Continues Hot

    The UK inflation metric for September continues to run hot. The CPIH has increased by 0.4% in September after rising by 0.3% in August and 0.7% in July. Its three-month rate of growth is at 5.7%, clearly excessive, relative to the 2% target of the Bank of England, however, there is substantial deceleration from the 6-month annualized pace of 9.4%; the 3-Mo pace also is weaker than the 8.8% pace over 12-months. Still, one year ago this month this measure was increasing at a 2.9% annual rate also above target but this month’s year-over-year gain of 8.8% as well as its lower 3-month pace exceeds the year-over-year pace from a year ago.

    The same measure excluding food alcohol and tobacco (that I will refer to as the core) increased by 0.4% in September after rising 0.5% in August and 0.4% in July. This measure runs at a 5.6% annual rate over three months and has accelerated compared to 6-months where the rate was 5.2% annualized. The 5.6% pace compares to a 12-month pace of 5.8%, barely any deceleration at all.

    Core shows mixed results: the 6- and 6-Mo pace are off peak; 12-Mo still accelerating All the acceleration in the UK CPI measure over three months is in the core reflecting a diminished rose for energy and food prices; core inflation continues to run hot and shows no real sign of deceleration as it runs at a rather steady too-strong pace.

    The diffusion calculation which measures the breadth of inflation across 10 categories plus the core measure shows diffusion at 45.5 in September. For diffusion, the key value is ‘50.’ Above 50 more than half of the components are showing inflation acceleration period to period. Whereas, below 50, more of them are showing deceleration. These measures are comparing the breadth of inflation’s rise or fall in one period to another period. In August, inflation accelerated with diffusion at 54.5 indicating marginally more acceleration than deceleration for the inflation rate. But then in July, despite a headline gain of 0.7%, and a core gain of 0.4%, the month-to-month diffusion measure clocked 27.3 indicating a broad step down in inflation compared to the month before (when the headline rose 0.8% and the core by 0.7% month-to-month).

    Sequential data show diffusion at 63.6 over 3-months compared to 6-months. The 6-month measure shows diffusion at 54.5 compared to its 12-month pace. Over 12-months diffusion is at 100 indicating acceleration in inflation across all the categories compared to the inflation rate of 12-months earlier.

    The sequential numbers show us that inflation is not simply the matter of one or two categories that are accelerating because the breadth of inflation is clearly across most categories and is not the result of some intense increases in just a few categories with large weights that are driving the headline higher. This is the sort of information that diffusion can deliver to us.

    **The United Kingdom continues to have inflation problems **with strong inflation represented in the headline pace and the core pace and across all the sequential time horizons. UK inflation trends muddles without a clear-cut patterns and with the pace of inflation, however measured, simply far too high. The inflation news may not be terrible and may not be a lot worse this month than last month...but it’s not any better either. At the same time the economy is facing weaker growth; that combination of events puts the Bank of England in a difficult spot. UK policy is in an extremely challenging situation. The government's intended fiscal plan has been forced to be withdrawn after it had adverse market effects. But the central bank will certainly stay on a tightening path but will be able to move in a more measured pace because of the encroaching weakness of the economy and some of the financial market jitters that have emerged.

  • The Zew economic indicators for the macro economy for the Euro-Area, for Germany, and for the US decline significantly in October. The Euro-Area diffusion reading fell from -58.9 in September to an October reading of -70.6. In Germany, the diffusion index deteriorated to -72.2 in October from -60.5 in September. And the US deterioration was from a +1.2 reading for September to -13.4 in October. These are substantial deteriorations. They have left the Euro-Area with a queue standing in it's 18.9th percentile, Germany in its 19.1 percentile, and the US and its 31.4 percentile. These are reading that have been lower only one third to one-fifth of the time (The US has the less weak standing).

    Economic expectations for Germany and the US showed mixed trends. For Germany, the macroeconomic expectation reading improved very slightly to -59.2 in October from -61.9 in September. This reading still leaves it below the August-22 level. And the US the macroeconomic outlook deteriorated to 45.6 in October from 39.6 in September. Both the German and the US queue standings post October readings that are extremely weak. The German reading has been this weak or weaker 1.4% of the time; the US reading has been this week or week or 5.7% of the time – not much difference.

    Inflation expectations that had revived a little bit in September have been sharply reduced in October as their trend decline continues. The Euro-area inflation expectations reading fell to a -35.8 diffusion index reading in October from -12.1 in September; in Germany inflation expectations fell to -35.2 in October from -9.7 in September. In the US inflation expectations fell to minus -71.0 in October from -50 in September. The Zew financial experts are coming to fear inflation less as they come to recognize weaker macroeconomic conditions and as they continue to hold extremely weak expectations for future growth. Inflation expectations have been reduced to a 4.4 percentile standing in the Euro-Area, to a 14.8 percentile standing in Germany and to a new all-time series low in the US. This does not mean inflation is going away; but it means the assessment is that there is a high probability that inflation has peaked. At some point diminished economic activity and poor expectations for the future must result in less inflation pressure.

    However, on the interest rate front for the Euro-Area we see a diffusion reading of 92.6 in October compared to 93.3 in September it's a small reduction that probably doesn't really mean anything because the readings are still so high- in the 90th percentile. Clearly the Zew experts continue to see the ECB raising rates. And in the US also there's a slight diminution of pressures in short term rates as the October diffusion index falls to 87.3 from 89.7 in September. That's another very modest and not noteworthy change in expectations. And the case of the Euro-Area, that diffusion reading is in its 98.9th percentile. For the US, the reading is in its 91st percentile. In both cases expectations for higher short-term rates are extremely strong. And that is more the point than that there was some very modest backing off.

    Moving on to long-term rates, we see pressure coming off long term rates expected in both Germany and in the US. In October, the German diffusion index falls to 48.7 from 55.2 in September. In the US, the reading falls to 40.6 in October from 50.7 in September. The lower diffusion readings imply less pressure on long term interest rates. In Germany, the standing of that diffusion index is in its 60.9 queue percentile, showing that expectations for long rate increases are above their historic median ( the median occurs that at a queue standing at the 50th percentile). In the US, the queue standing is at its 41st percentile, below its historic median.

    Stock market expectations have improved slightly for the Euro-Area area and in Germany; they are marginally weaker in the US. In the Euro-Area stock market expectations flip from a - 5.2 reading in September to a + 2.5 reading in October. Similarly, in Germany, the October reading flipped to a +1.2 reading from a -5.9 reading in September. The US the October diffusion reading edged down to 11.7 from a September reading of 12.5. The Euro-Area and German readings are still both in the lower two percentile of their historic queues of observations for stock market expectations. And in the US the reading is a bottom 25 percentile reading at its 25.7 percentile mark. These are weak queue percentile standings for all three areas; however, the weakest standings are for Germany and the Euro-Area.