Recent Updates

  • Euro area: Flash Consumer Confidence (Apr)
  • Ireland: Producer & Wholesale Price Indexes (Mar)
  • UK: Capital Issuance (Mar)
  • Spain: Trade in Constant Prices, Trade in Goods (Feb)
  • Germany: Federal Budget, PPI, Monthly Tax Revenue (Mar), Short-term Indicator (Feb), Public Sector Finance (Q4)
  • Colombia: Imports (Feb); Brazil: IPCA-15 (Apr)
  • Turkey: Non-Domestic PPI, House Sales, Central Government and Domestic Debt by Instrument, External Debt by Lender, Domestic
  • more updates...

Economy in Brief

U.S.-- The Jobless Rate Is High And Labor Force Participation Is Low
by Tom Moeller  May 18, 2011

The current unemployment rate of 9.0% is down from its October, 2009 peak of 10.1%. The decline occurred due to negligible 0.9% growth in employment during that period. The economic recovery has been slow. Further impetus for the decline, however, was the 0.4% decline in the labor force. Individuals are just not looking for work like they had been. In fact, that downward bias has been in place for some time. The implication for economic growth is that consumers are not in a position to spend freely.

In 2011, the U.S. population aged 16 years or over equaled 238.9M. That total was accompanied by a low 64.2% workforce participation rate. This participation rate is down from the peak ten years ago of 67.0%. Had the decline not occurred, the unemployment rate could be 2-to-3 percentage points higher than it currently is.

Several forces have been in play, causing labor force participation to decline -- some cyclical, some structural. The cyclical factors are related to the weak economic recovery. Workers have become discouraged by their inability to find employment. Six and one-half million individuals are not in the labor force but want a job now. That compares to 4.5 million persons during the 2000 low. The structural factors lowering labor force participation are many. The aging of the baby boom generation has pulled some workers into retirement. Second, the earlier rise in adult woman's' labor force participation rate has topped out. Finally, young adults are staying in college longer. Partially offsetting these influences is the delaying of retirement by older individuals due to better health and longer life spans.

The bottom line is that the recent, small decline in the unemployment rate indicates some healing of the labor market. However, the rate of improvement has been quite slow for reasons that will not go away quickly, even if job growth picks up. Therefore the unemployment rate is likely to remain elevated for some time. Moreover, the unemployment rate including marginally attached and persons working part-time for economic reasons currently is 16%. The analysis above indicates it may be closer to 20%. In this environment, counting on robust consumer spending to fuel the economic recovery seems implausible.

The employment data are contained in Haver's USECON database.

U.S. Labor Force 2011 'YTD 2006 2001 1991 1981
Participation Rate 64.2% 66.2% 66.8% 66.2% 63.9%
Labor Force (Million) 123.3 151.4 143.8 126.4 108.7
Population (Million) 238.9 228.8 215.1 190.9 170.1
large image