Recent Updates

  • Israel: Average Housing Prices (Q2)
  • Japan: NCI Economic Activity Index (Aug)
  • US: NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index (Aug)
  • Canada: Wholesale trade, MSIO (June)
  • Pakistan: Foreign Currency Deposits and Utilization (JUL)
  • more updates...

Economy in Brief

Sluggish Exports, Surging Imports Produce Big Trade Deficit in India
by Carol Stone March 25, 2005

Some months ago, we wrote here expressing surprise that India sustains a deficit in merchandise trade. Media coverage might give the impression that it, like China, runs a substantial surplus. But this is not the case, and in fact, the trade deficit is gapping wider persistently. It averaged 83 billion rupees a month in 2004, with the first three quarters of the year equal to 3.2% of GDP. In February, it was a record 161 billion rupees.

As seen in the graph, developments in both exports and imports have contributed to the widening of the trade deficit. Exports have flattened. Strange as that may seem, they have hovered near 280 billion rupees monthly since last June. Among the most important products, cotton yarn and clothing shipments have steadied or even drifted lower. Jewelry and gems are very erratic, but a moving average gives some suggestion of plateauing or edging down a bit. By contrast, machinery sales have remained firm.

Imports have risen sharply. As noted in the table below, they were up more than 31% in 2004, although the most recent, February figure is "just" 5.7% above a year earlier. Petroleum is an obvious culprit, up 35.5% in 2004 and a whopping 80.0% in February from February 2004. But other items show strength as well: gold and steel in particular each rose roundly 60% in 2004 as a whole.

We argued before that a good portion of Indian imports are probably used to produce items for export or as investment in expanding production facilities; this enumeration of individual import items would seem to corroborate those comments. Thus, one seems to hear little about a burgeoning Indian trade gap. Further, until the middle of last year, the widely publicized work in the services industries along with surpluses in invisibles and income accounts were more than enough to cover the trade shortfall, so the current account held a surplus. However, in Q3 last year, reductions in those positive component balances joined the wider trade deficit to produce a deficit in the overall current account as well. With the subsequently larger trade gaps, it will likely be difficult for those services and income inflows to regenerate a surplus in the current account.

India: Trade  Feb 2005* Jan 2005* Year Ago 2004 2003 2002
Exports % Change -4.7 -0.6 4.2 23.0 13.6 16.5
Imports % Change 5.7 0.1 29.0 31.6 20.6 15.1
Balance (Billion Rupees) -160.90 -18.49 -60.16 -82.96** -48.19** -28.33**
large image